by Rev. Joan Van Becelaere, District Executive, Ohio-Meadville District of the UUA
We Unitarian Universalists are called to respect the worth and dignity of all – regardless of race, ethnicity, documentation status or citizenship. We promote justice, equity and compassion in all human relations and respect the web of all existence.
Given the principles we proclaim and our call to live what we believe, it is important that we become aware of what is taking place our own backyards in regard to increasingly questionable and illegal tactics by US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE).
The stories below highlight why we must, as people of faith, ethics and compassion, be concerned about immigration reform. The stories raise difficult questions about the state of our society and the attitudes and agendas of those that we entrust to uphold our laws.
When people are dehumanized, oppressed or threatened because of their identities, we are called to Stand on the Side of Love. http://www.standingonthesideoflove.org/
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: Thursday, April 14, 2011 by Alliance for Immigrants Rights and Reform Michigan
Leaders Demand Accountability as ICE Tactics Worsen
Detroit – Faith and community leaders gathered on a telephonic press conference this afternoon to voice their condemnation and concern about ICE’s abusive tactics.
The incidents that have come to light include ICE officials detaining a U.S. citizen, denying a pregnant woman her medication and throwing a man through a wall during a home raid.
Last week, AIR released this list of demands which has not been fulfilled:
1) Pursuant to ICE’s own guidelines, “Field Guidance on Enforcement Actions or Investigative Activities At or Near Sensitive Locations,” we demand to know who authorized enforcement actions at schools, if anyone, and why.
2) We demand that ICE immediately respect their own policy, and end all enforcement activities near schools, churches, mosques, community centers and health clinics, and ends warrant-less searches and raids of homes.
3) We demand that the officers involved in Thursday’s incident here at Hope Elementary School be identified and disciplined.
4) We demand that officers involved in the warrant—less search of Maria and Rogelio Perez’s home be identified and disciplined.
5) We demand that Rebecca Adducci submit a “Civil Rights Plan” to the community that specifically addresses how problems like this will be prevented from occurring in the future.
Ryan Bates, Director of the Alliance for Immigrants Rights & Reform – Michigan – made this statement:
“It’s clear that these are not isolated incidents, but rather a pattern of abusive and often illegal enforcement. The Detroit ICE Office is out of control, and ICE leadership must take immediate, concrete steps to hold those responsible to account. Immigration enforcement must be conducted with respect for our laws, and ICE’s own policies.”
Ruben Torres, a U.S. citizen told the story of how he was detained by ICE agents for over an hour, despite showing his drivers’ license, social security card and union card. He expressed his frustration and anger by saying:
“I’m a U.S. citizen; I shouldn’t have to carry my birth-certificate around because my last name is Torres. After nearly an hour on the side of the road he let me go. He never showed me a warrant or gave me any reason for why I was stopped. It was clear that they came after me because I am Latino. In my opinion this was racism through and through. Immigration shouldn’t be stopping people because of their race. That is not the America that I was raised in.”
Jorge Deanda, who is also a U.S. citizen suffered at the hands of Detroit ICE agents when these entered his house illegally without a warrant and without his consent. Mr. Deanda said:
“What kind of America is this, what kind of United States?”
Jessie Rossman and ACLU attorney explained that there are certain protections that are so fundamental that they apply not only to U.S. citizens but to all people regardless of their immigration status. Protection against unreasonable searches and seizures is one of them.
Last week, Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) issued a statement admitting that they had broken their own policies during the stake-out at Hope of Detroit Academy and would take appropriate steps to address any concerns from the community. However, these are not isolated issues and the appropriate steps have not been taken to remedy the situation. ICE agents continue to abuse their power and conduct illegal, even violent searches while not being disciplined or held accountable for their actions. This is clearly a violation of these fundamental protections under law and is becoming a common trend with ICE not only in Detroit but throughout our country.
Reverend Jack Eggleston from the South East Michigan Evangelical Lutheran Church of America spoke and condemned these abuses:
Cases of Abuse and Legal Violations by Detroit ICE Agents:
Roseville, MI: Mother Strip-Searched in Front of Son
On May 5th, 2010, Ivan Nikolov and his mother, Valentina Ivanova, were detained in Calhoun County detention facility. During intake, Ivan was forced to watch his mother, who was in tears, while she was strip-searched. There was a small, shoulder-length screen separating the two individuals, but the incident was very embarrassing to both Ivan and his mother. When Ms. Ivanov expressed her objections to being strip-searched in front of her son, Officer Jolin (sp?) told her “You’re lucky we don’t just shoot you in the head.”
Cincinnati, OH: Immigrant Shoved Through Wall
On the afternoon of February 12, 2011, a Cincinnati family was at home when they heard what the mother, Beatriz, described as a “soft, childlike knock on the door.” When they answered the door, immigration agents burst in, and proceeded to search the apartment aggressively. They did not show the family a warrant, but did show a picture of an unfamiliar Latino man. The agents man-handled Beatriz’ husband without provocation, and shoved the man against the wall so hard that he broke through the drywall. The Detroit ICE office has jurisdiction over Ohio.
Detroit, MI: ICE Illegally Searched Home, Failed to Provide Proper Medical Care to Pregnant Woman
On March 23, 2011, Rogelio Perez Vazquez returned to his home to find ICE agents outside. They asked for his brother, and Rogelio told him that he did not live with him. The agents asked to perform a search, and Rogelio denied them permission asked to see a warrant. The agents only showed Rogelio a badge, and Rogelio reiterated that they did not have permission to enter his home. They entered anyway, and found his wife, Maria Perez, who was six months pregnant at the time. ICE detained Ms. Perez, separating her from her husband and three U.S. citizen children. When Mr. Perez came to the Rosa Parks ICE facility to bring his wife her medication, ICE agents refused to give Ms Perez the medicine. Ms. Perez was also denied appropriate access to doctors and nutritious food while in immigration jail.
Detroit, MI: ICE Pulled Over, Interrogated, and Detained U.S. Citizen
On March 24, 2011, Ruben Torres was pulled over on the M-10 Service Drive, near Howard and Abbot, by an unmarked car of the type typically used by ICE. Torres was born in Detroit and is a U.S. citizen. The officer interrogated Torres and demanded to see his visa. Torres showed him his social security card, driver’s license, and union membership cards and continued to explain that he is a U.S. citizen. The officer insisted that Torres produce either a visa or a birth certificate to prove his claims. He told Torres that he believed Torres’ “visa” expired in 2004 and that he should “stop lying” about being a U.S. citizen. The officer detained Torres for about an hour and then released him.
Detroit, MI: ICE Stalked and Arrested Parents at School
On March 31, ICE agents were active throughout the morning at Hope of Detroit Academy. At approximately 7:30 AM, agents were either waiting for Jose Maldonado Plasencia at the school or followed him there. After dropping his child off at school, Mr. Maldonado and his wife were followed from the school and stopped approximately a block away. Mr. Maldonado was detained, though ICE never obtained prior authorization for performing enforcement at a school.
ICE subsequently followed two additional families to the school from their neighborhood approximately a mile away. The families noticed that they were being followed by at least three vehicles of the type used by immigration (SUV’s and sedans with tinted windows). After dropping their children off, the families took refuge in the school, unsure of what to do. Immigration agents then took up positions around the school, playground, and church, lying in wait for the families. In the meantime, other parents and children began to panic, placing dozens of calls into the school’s office wondering if their children were safe.
At approximately 9:00 AM, AIR Director Ryan Bates arrived on the scene and interviewed the families. Bates then intervened with ICE and asked if they had a warrant. The officer admitted that they had no warrant, and Bates asked the officers to leave. The officer complied, and a convoy of five or six vehicles departed from positions around the school, church, and playground.
Many parents were too afraid to pick up their children, and attendance at the school is still low because many parents are simply too scared to bring their children to school.
Detroit, MI: ICE Surrounded Another Elementary School
On April 7, 2011, after the incident at Hope of Detroit Academy came to light, parents at Neinas Elementary School reported seeing immigration agents circling the school in the afternoon when they came to pick up their children at approximately 2:30 PM. The witness saw at least one ICE and one Border Patrol vehicle outside the school. She was able to identify the Border Patrol vehicle by the green markings (Customs and Border Protection), and the ICE officer passed close enough to her that she was able to see the word “ICE” written on his uniform. Once again, parents were thrown into panic. No detention was reported.
Wixom, MI: ICE Illegally Searched Home, Interrogated U.S. Citizen
On April 7, 2011, ICE agents detained Luis Rodriguez outside his home. Although he did not give the officers consent to enter the house, they did so anyway. There they found U.S. citizen Jorge Deana, who was sleeping. Deana asked what they were doing there and whether they had a warrant. Officers did not show Deana a warrant, but instead demanded to see his identification. Officers left, with Rodriguez in custody, after Deana claimed he was a US Citizen.
Share